Further to the events described in previous posts I think it best to provide a full chronological sequence of events. I think it is also important to clarify the importance of humanity in saving the Minbari both as a species and a civilisation.
In 2262 Sinclair and Delenn travel back in time, intending to take the previous Babylon Station forward as a replacement/supplement to Babylon 5. They return to 2267 in the White Star, leaving Zathras to pilot B4.
The second Earth-Minbari War quickly turns into a conflict between anti-Shadow telepaths and the Minbari Warrior Caste, with Clark loyalists on the side of the former and the Shadows fighting alongside the latter.
I would also make Londo Mollari secretly responsible for the Centauri-ISA War. This would take place in the year of Londo's death at the hands of G'kar in 2278. He initiates hostilities in order to remove the Drakh presence on Centauri Prime without initiating a civil war and arousing suspicions among his Drakh keepers.
1260 CE: A replacement supply base miraculously appears during the last Shadow War, allowing the Minbari to successfully prosecute their war against the Shadows.
-Valen leads Minbari-led coalition against the Shadows.
1261-He marries and has a child.
1262-Valen forms the Anlashok to guard against the Shadows' return.
1264-Before disappearing, he forms the Grey Council to create balance between the three castes.
2245 to 2249 CE: Earth-Minbari War.
-Conflict ends when Minbari surrender* at the Battle of the Line. They do not give a reason.
2251: Construction begins on the first of the Babylon stations.
2254: Shortly after being constructed, Babylon 4 disappears.
2257: Vorlon Ambassador Kosh arrives at Babylon 5.
2258
-Sinclair and Garibaldi rescue the crew of Babylon 4 when it suddenly returns.
-William Morgan Clark becomes President of the Earth Alliance after the death of his predecessor. The Minbari inform him of their belief that Minbari souls are being reincarnated as humans.
-An incurable plague infects inhabitants of the Markeb homeworld. After spreading to other colonies and outposts, the Markeb die out.
2259: New Centauri Emperor launches "pre-emptive" war against Narn Regime after the murder of the previous emperor's son and Prime Minister.
2261
-Death Cloud surrounds Narn homeworld, effectively ending Narn-Centauri conflict.
-Vorlons respond against Shadow attacks by destroying planets housing Shadow bases.
-Gaim and Brakiri representatives ask Sinclair for Earth Alliance aid. The result is President Clark disbands the Senate and declares martial law. Officially, the Minbari are responsible for the attacks.
-Kosh is assassinated, Vorlons cease their attacks.
-Telepath colony established on Babylon 5, much to Garibaldi's disapproval. He resigns and begins work in the private sector.
-Doctor Steven Franklin goes "Walkabout".
-Zack Allan replaces Garibaldi as Chief of Security.
2262
-The Shadows establish a significant base on Centauri Prime.
-White Star prototype arrives carrying Marcus Cole and Lyta Alexander.
-"Ship of Tears"; Bester arrives on the station requesting aid against a mutual enemy. Using the White Star, Sinclair, Bester and Lyta rescue two hundred and fifty cybernetically-enhanced telepaths in stasis. Sinclair and G'kar realise the Shadows are vulnerable to telepaths and hope to use telepath aboard their own vessels to block telepathic interference.
-Garibaldi is kidnapped by Talia Winters and human Shadow agents during a business trip to Mars. Justin and Morden give him the Shadows' version of events and motives then send him to Bester to be brainwashed.
-Leaving Ivanova in charge, Sinclair, Zathras and Delenn use the Great Machine on Epsilon 3 to travel back in time.
-Ivanova organises the Rangers and the League of Non-Aligned Worlds into a fighting force against the Shadows. She has aid from the Narn, who provide reinforcements for security on the station and some of their surviving warships.
-Lennir and Sakai join the Rangers and become lovers, special dispensation given for non-Warrior caste Minbari and humans to join on recommendation by Delenn and Kosh (2259), later Sinclair and G'kar (2262) also.
-Epsilon 3 is used to re-locate refugees.
-Earth-Minbari War restarts after renegade Minbari and an Earth Force task force launch a simultaneous assault on Babylon 5, resulting in the station's evacuation and destruction.
-Ivanova relocates personnel and residents to Epsilon 3 after setting the local Jumpgate to overload. This desperate measure destroys several Earth cruisers, cripples a number of destroyers and prevents reinforcements from arriving.
2263 to 2268:
-Minbari Worker caste begins construction of the White Star fleet and Franklin resurfaces after being almost killed. After a brief sabbatical, he returns to duty.
-With the Shadows distracted by the second Minbari war, the Vorlons begin attacks on the colonies of neutral planets, seemingly in order to force neutral parties to choose sides in the vast conflict. Millions of civilians are killed and displaced.
-Babylon 4 is recovered. It soon replaces Babylon 5 as "Babylon Prime" and begins a two and-a-half year long voyage to the nearest intact Jumpgate (assuming B4 can reach speeds of 1/5th c and the next Jumpgate is six light months distant).
-A brainwashed Michael Garibaldi returns to Babylon prime
-Vir Cotto assassinates Centauri Emperor Cartagia on Narn. Londo frees Narn and rids Centauri Prime of the Shadows when he becomes Prime Minister.
-President Clark re-establishes the senate and gives it most of its former powers. His nominated members are slowly replaced by elected members.
-Sinclair and Delenn return in the White Star. Sakai gives birth to Lennir's child.
-The Shadows are defeated openly during Sinclair's absence but the conflict creates a civil war in Psi Corps and conflict between the Religious and Warrior Minbari Castes. Edgars' Industries unleashes an anti-telepath virus. All telepaths on Mars are infected.
-Admittance is given for former EarthForce officers to join the Rangers, partly to increase membership and partly to encourage defections from Clark's military.
-Sinclair's outing as Valen ends the Minbari Caste War. Minbari Warriors begin to re-join the Rangers and members of the Worker and Religious are now also allowed to join the order as full members. Previously, the roles of the other two castes were limited to ship maintenance, medical support and supervising combat training.
-Ivanova, Franklin, Lennir, G'kar and Londo found the Interstellar Alliance, with Babylon Prime, Epsilon 3, Narn and the Minbari Federation as founding members. Most former League worlds eventually join also, the show of solidarity finally ending the Vorlon rampage.
-Lyta removes Garibaldi's brainwashing. He briefly re-joins station security but then leaves to become an advisor to the Narn Regime. Zack remains Chief of Security.
-Humans, Drazi and Narn are permitted to join the Rangers.
2269
-Londo Mollari becomes Centauri Emperor.
-The re-established Earth Alliance senate requests aid from the ISA and Rangers in finding a cure to the telepath virus.
-Mars joins the ISA as an independent member. It retains ties to Earth but is no longer ruled by the Earth Alliance senate. Its citizens can still vote in presidential elections and join Earth Force.
-The Centauri Republic and Narn Regime formally join the ISA.
-All citizens of ISA planets can now join the Rangers.
-Londo sends Vir Cotto to Babylon Prime as his ambassador. Secretly, Vir also organises an anti-Drakh rebellion.
-Lyta Alexander destroys Z'ha'dum, the Shadow homeworld by telepathically initiating planetary self-destruct. This convinces the Vorlons and other remaining First Ones to leave the galaxy. It also thwarts Bester's hopes of removing the Shadow implants from his lover and finding a cure to the telepath virus.
-Clark commits suicide after the Shadows leave.
-The Earth Alliance joins the ISA and abolishes the Psi Corps.
2270:
-Sinclair and Delenn return in the White Star.
-Sakai gives birth to Lennir's child.
-Sinclair and Delenn marry during Delenn's first pregnancy. They are captured during the 2278 war against the Centauri Republic and (secretly) Drakh.
2271: Lyse Hampton-Edgars hires Garibaldi to find her missing-and wanted on charges of attempted genocide-husband William.
2272: The Narn Regime re-locates to the Markab homeworld. With the absence of technology on Narn, most of the Shadow telepaths are relocated there in the hopes of their eventual rehabilitation. A number of so-called free telepaths, mostly part of the Byron Movement on Babylon Prime, are also allowed to settle there as caretakers.
2274: The Rangers aid Garibaldi in apprehending William Edgars. During his trial, Lise divorces him and marries Michael Garibaldi. They later have a daughter and settle on Mars, with occasional business trips and holidays to Earth and Babylon Prime.
2275: Londo nominates Vir Cotto as Centauri Prime Minister. He uses his new position to secretly relocate civilians away from military targets close to the capital. He also encourages military cadets to join the Rangers.
2278
-A series of random attacks is blamed on the Centauri Republic, causing it to be expelled from the ISA.
-Vir becomes the new Centauri Emperor after Londo's death and agrees to pay reparations to Alliance members for their losses.
-A new class of destroyers is developed by the ISA using some of the reparation funds to replace the White Stars lost in various conflicts and campaigns.
-Thirty out of the two hundred and fifty implanted telepaths remain in stasis. Some are used to sabotage the unmanned Centauri warships used in the war while the remainder are used against the Drakh in a similar fashion, being secretly smuggled aboard awaiting activation. On activation, the telepaths instantly try to interface with any available technology, causing irreparable damage to a ship's systems.
2280: Centauri aid ISA during conflict with Drakh hordes. They are re-admitted in 2282.
(Note added 15.2.2017)
*Query: what does this surrender actually mean? Is Minbar actually occupied and/or the military as in the Warrior Caste disarmed or disbanded? Does this explain how Delenn and Sinclair could have know each other long enough to have a close friendship and how so many humans join the Rangers much earlier than I would have imagined i.e. early enough to be a presence on Babylon 5 in 2259 ?
Monday, 13 February 2017
Sinclair B5 / Valen B Prime
Further to "Babylon 5:The Sinclair Years" I think it fair to propose a scenario that follows more closely the televised events of Babylon 5-but if Jeffrey Sinclair were to be the stations commander throughout the five years Babylon 5 was broadcast.
Note: the following is a "finished draft idea" to be expanded upon later.
Beginning in 2261 the Vorlons retaliate against the Shadows after a Shadow Death Cloud obliterates Narn. This is both as a result of the Shadows being "outed" on ISN and Narn forces achieving a sudden victory in their assault on Gorash prime. The Narn-Centauri war had reached a stalemate and had failed to draw in the other major powers, contrary to Shadow interests.
As a result of this, Shadows assassinate Kosh. Kosh's replacement heralds a change in Vorlon-and Shadow-policy, with both sides attacking colonies belonging to those neutral powers whose territory hadn't been captured by the Centauri in order to force them to choose sides. Note: query whether Kosh needs a replacement or simply that his death initiates a sudden change in Vorlon policy, seemingly aiding the Shadows instead of destroying them. Query event: Vorlons actually cease their attacks?
The scene in which League members (specifically the Gaim and Brakiri) ask Earth for help in the changed scenario becomes the catalyst for Babylon 5 seceding from Earth control and EA President Clark disbanding the senate. Victims of the Shadows' onslaught request that Sinclair ask the Earth Alliance to send military and humanitarian aid. Sinclair then contacts the Senate and explains briefly about the Shadow (and Vorlon at this point?) raids against the League of Non-Aligned Worlds and the need for Earth to take a stand against them. However, as this is the first time anyone in the senate have heard of the Shadows, Clark (wishing to both remain a Shadow ally and to hide their existence from the general public) declares martial law on Earth and disbands the senate. In protest, Babylon 5, Mars and Proxima Centauri colonies declare independence. Clark then orders a travel ban and embargo on Babylon 5 and sends troops to reinforce his forces in the outer colonies.
Sinclair and Delenn take the White Star* (or perhaps the Narn cruiser Ch'tok, in return for providing G'kar with information on the Shadows and Rangers?) back in time to find a replacement station. They bring Babylon 4 into the present time after thwarting a sabotage effort by Shadow allies and successfully evacuating the station's crew. On returning to the present Sinclair begins to have memories of being the Minbari spiritual figure Valen. This begins to affect his relationship with his wife, Catherine Sakai, and he becomes romantically closer to Delenn. Catherine Sakai, in turn, begins a relationship with Delenn's aide, Lenier. This influx of human DNA halts the decline in Minbari population, saving them from eventual and inevitable extinction. The Narn homeworld is restored to a semblance of normality when the Death Cloud joins the Shadows' war effort-at first against Vorlon-allied systems and then against neutral League worlds, seemingly in league with the Vorlons, on the assassination of Kosh.
In my alternative scenario, we the viewer is introduced to the Rangers from G'kar's perspective. Specifically, the scene where he asks Delenn about Rangers, implying they are human and also Minbari. Before this, the viewer would occasionally see humans and Minbari dressed in black and be party to Michael Garibaldi uncovering both Kosh and Delenn training Lurkers. Garibaldi being Garibaldi he first assumes the Lurkers are getting organised so they can take over the station but is assured by Delenn that this is not the case.
It transpired that a thousand years previously the Vorlons nominated a Human to unite the disparate Minbari forces in order to have have more time to rebuild their own forces. Introducing a leader with an objective view to the warring clans and caste system allowed the Vorlons to produce a united Minbari society. The introduction of human DNA also prevented the decline in population among the Minbari. Sinclair was then taken to Vorlon, preserved and re-introduced into human society (with temporary amnesia) in the 23rd century. Sinclair was specifically chosen because he is among a small percentage of humans who are genetically compatible with a small percentage of Minbari and was surgically altered to fulfil this role. Delenn, meanwhile, was specifically transformed into a half human half Minbari to bridge the species gap and represent the ideal of the Anlashok/Rangers.
*I note that there are several scenarios whereby Sheridan or Ivanova take the White Star out on missions, in "Matters of Honour", "Voices of Authority", "Messages From Earth" and "Ship of Tears". I would propose that in this alternative 'Sinclair' scenario a variety of ships are used before the White Star fleet is finally introduced.
I think it would be more believable to introduce the new fleet later in order to give time for it to be constructed and for her Ranger crew to be trained. Sinclair and Delenn could use the resources of Babylon 4 in the construction of (some of) the White Stars while also having access to a captured Centauri cruiser, the Narn warship Ch'tok and, perhaps, a prototype Warlock-class destroyer provided by General William Hague.
Sequence of events:
1260-Valen leads Minbari-led coalition against the Shadows.
1261-He marries and has a child.
1262-Valen forms the Anlashok to guard against the Shadows' return.
1264-Before disappearing, he forms the Grey Council to create balance between the three castes.
2259-New Centauri Emperor launches "pre-emptive" war against Narn Regime.
2261-Death Cloud surrounds Narn homeworld, effectively ending Narn-Centauri conflict.
Vorlon fleet assaults planets that have not taken sides in the conflict, those that have sided with the Shadows and those hosting Shadow bases.
Shadows use Death Cloud to retaliate, Vorlons respond by using Planet Killer to destroy planets with Shadow bases.
Vorlon and Shadow attacks suddenly cease when Kosh is assassinated.
General Hague supplies Sinclair with a prototype Warlock-class destroyer, knowing that Clark will use the weapon against rebels on Mars. The same vessel is then used by Sinclair, Delenn and Zathras, to "hijack" Babylon 4.
2262-Shadows resume attacks, targeting neutral worlds. They also establish a base on Centauri Prime.
White Star prototype arrives carrying Marcus Cole and Lyta Alexander
Gaim and Brakiri representatives ask Sinclair for Earth Alliance aid, result is Clark disbands the Senate and declares martial law. Officially, the Minbari are responsible for the attacks.
Telepath colony established on the station much to Garibaldi's disapproval. He resigns and begins work in the private sector.
Earth-Minbari War restarts after renegade Minbari and an Earth Force task force launch a simultaneous assault on Babylon 5, resulting in the station's evacuation and destruction.
In order to gain an edge, Clark orders Psi Corps to place telepaths aboard Earth destroyers to track Minbari vessels in hyperspace. Instead, they end up tracking Shadow vessels. With telepaths aboard both Earth destroyers and Babylon 5, the Shadows are effectively defeated. Clark disbands the Psi Corps then commits suicide.
Overview of Second Minbari War: The conflict begins when the Windswords emerge from hyperspace at the same time as pro-Clark forces launch an attack on Babylon 5. Overwhelmed, Ivanova and Sinclair overload the local jumpgate, destroying much of the Earth taskforce and preventing reinforcements from arriving. The surviving destroyers and cruisers leave Epsilon space, bemused at being on the same side as Minbari.
Earth attempts to restart hostilities, but the Grey Council deny the warrior caste the opportunity to kill their "soul brothers". Instead, many Warriors join the Rangers or help in B5's defence while others occupy the Markeb homeworld in exile.
Note: the following is a "finished draft idea" to be expanded upon later.
Beginning in 2261 the Vorlons retaliate against the Shadows after a Shadow Death Cloud obliterates Narn. This is both as a result of the Shadows being "outed" on ISN and Narn forces achieving a sudden victory in their assault on Gorash prime. The Narn-Centauri war had reached a stalemate and had failed to draw in the other major powers, contrary to Shadow interests.
As a result of this, Shadows assassinate Kosh. Kosh's replacement heralds a change in Vorlon-and Shadow-policy, with both sides attacking colonies belonging to those neutral powers whose territory hadn't been captured by the Centauri in order to force them to choose sides. Note: query whether Kosh needs a replacement or simply that his death initiates a sudden change in Vorlon policy, seemingly aiding the Shadows instead of destroying them. Query event: Vorlons actually cease their attacks?
The scene in which League members (specifically the Gaim and Brakiri) ask Earth for help in the changed scenario becomes the catalyst for Babylon 5 seceding from Earth control and EA President Clark disbanding the senate. Victims of the Shadows' onslaught request that Sinclair ask the Earth Alliance to send military and humanitarian aid. Sinclair then contacts the Senate and explains briefly about the Shadow (and Vorlon at this point?) raids against the League of Non-Aligned Worlds and the need for Earth to take a stand against them. However, as this is the first time anyone in the senate have heard of the Shadows, Clark (wishing to both remain a Shadow ally and to hide their existence from the general public) declares martial law on Earth and disbands the senate. In protest, Babylon 5, Mars and Proxima Centauri colonies declare independence. Clark then orders a travel ban and embargo on Babylon 5 and sends troops to reinforce his forces in the outer colonies.
Sinclair and Delenn take the White Star* (or perhaps the Narn cruiser Ch'tok, in return for providing G'kar with information on the Shadows and Rangers?) back in time to find a replacement station. They bring Babylon 4 into the present time after thwarting a sabotage effort by Shadow allies and successfully evacuating the station's crew. On returning to the present Sinclair begins to have memories of being the Minbari spiritual figure Valen. This begins to affect his relationship with his wife, Catherine Sakai, and he becomes romantically closer to Delenn. Catherine Sakai, in turn, begins a relationship with Delenn's aide, Lenier. This influx of human DNA halts the decline in Minbari population, saving them from eventual and inevitable extinction. The Narn homeworld is restored to a semblance of normality when the Death Cloud joins the Shadows' war effort-at first against Vorlon-allied systems and then against neutral League worlds, seemingly in league with the Vorlons, on the assassination of Kosh.
In my alternative scenario, we the viewer is introduced to the Rangers from G'kar's perspective. Specifically, the scene where he asks Delenn about Rangers, implying they are human and also Minbari. Before this, the viewer would occasionally see humans and Minbari dressed in black and be party to Michael Garibaldi uncovering both Kosh and Delenn training Lurkers. Garibaldi being Garibaldi he first assumes the Lurkers are getting organised so they can take over the station but is assured by Delenn that this is not the case.
It transpired that a thousand years previously the Vorlons nominated a Human to unite the disparate Minbari forces in order to have have more time to rebuild their own forces. Introducing a leader with an objective view to the warring clans and caste system allowed the Vorlons to produce a united Minbari society. The introduction of human DNA also prevented the decline in population among the Minbari. Sinclair was then taken to Vorlon, preserved and re-introduced into human society (with temporary amnesia) in the 23rd century. Sinclair was specifically chosen because he is among a small percentage of humans who are genetically compatible with a small percentage of Minbari and was surgically altered to fulfil this role. Delenn, meanwhile, was specifically transformed into a half human half Minbari to bridge the species gap and represent the ideal of the Anlashok/Rangers.
*I note that there are several scenarios whereby Sheridan or Ivanova take the White Star out on missions, in "Matters of Honour", "Voices of Authority", "Messages From Earth" and "Ship of Tears". I would propose that in this alternative 'Sinclair' scenario a variety of ships are used before the White Star fleet is finally introduced.
I think it would be more believable to introduce the new fleet later in order to give time for it to be constructed and for her Ranger crew to be trained. Sinclair and Delenn could use the resources of Babylon 4 in the construction of (some of) the White Stars while also having access to a captured Centauri cruiser, the Narn warship Ch'tok and, perhaps, a prototype Warlock-class destroyer provided by General William Hague.
Sequence of events:
1260-Valen leads Minbari-led coalition against the Shadows.
1261-He marries and has a child.
1262-Valen forms the Anlashok to guard against the Shadows' return.
1264-Before disappearing, he forms the Grey Council to create balance between the three castes.
2259-New Centauri Emperor launches "pre-emptive" war against Narn Regime.
2261-Death Cloud surrounds Narn homeworld, effectively ending Narn-Centauri conflict.
Vorlon fleet assaults planets that have not taken sides in the conflict, those that have sided with the Shadows and those hosting Shadow bases.
Shadows use Death Cloud to retaliate, Vorlons respond by using Planet Killer to destroy planets with Shadow bases.
Vorlon and Shadow attacks suddenly cease when Kosh is assassinated.
General Hague supplies Sinclair with a prototype Warlock-class destroyer, knowing that Clark will use the weapon against rebels on Mars. The same vessel is then used by Sinclair, Delenn and Zathras, to "hijack" Babylon 4.
2262-Shadows resume attacks, targeting neutral worlds. They also establish a base on Centauri Prime.
White Star prototype arrives carrying Marcus Cole and Lyta Alexander
Gaim and Brakiri representatives ask Sinclair for Earth Alliance aid, result is Clark disbands the Senate and declares martial law. Officially, the Minbari are responsible for the attacks.
Telepath colony established on the station much to Garibaldi's disapproval. He resigns and begins work in the private sector.
Earth-Minbari War restarts after renegade Minbari and an Earth Force task force launch a simultaneous assault on Babylon 5, resulting in the station's evacuation and destruction.
In order to gain an edge, Clark orders Psi Corps to place telepaths aboard Earth destroyers to track Minbari vessels in hyperspace. Instead, they end up tracking Shadow vessels. With telepaths aboard both Earth destroyers and Babylon 5, the Shadows are effectively defeated. Clark disbands the Psi Corps then commits suicide.
Overview of Second Minbari War: The conflict begins when the Windswords emerge from hyperspace at the same time as pro-Clark forces launch an attack on Babylon 5. Overwhelmed, Ivanova and Sinclair overload the local jumpgate, destroying much of the Earth taskforce and preventing reinforcements from arriving. The surviving destroyers and cruisers leave Epsilon space, bemused at being on the same side as Minbari.
Earth attempts to restart hostilities, but the Grey Council deny the warrior caste the opportunity to kill their "soul brothers". Instead, many Warriors join the Rangers or help in B5's defence while others occupy the Markeb homeworld in exile.
Monday, 12 December 2016
Empire versus Federation
I think that either Anakin Skywalker or Darth Vader (taking them as different characters) could defeat Starfleet single handed if he was piloting a B-Wing.
It can be difficult to compare the offensive and defensive capacities of say the Empire and the United Federation of Planets, but I would say it is certain that the defensive systems (shields) used by Starfleet are not capable of absorbing 100% of the energy from most offensive weapons systems.
Similarly, the weapons on a B-Wing (Star Wars: Rebels season two) are comparable to a starship's phasers on a higher setting. Combined with his obvious piloting skill, Vader could easily defeat Starfleet one task force at a time.
A caveat: this ultimately assumes however that Starfleet will not "fight dirty". Considering the wide array of weapons that the Federation is actually capable of using, they could inflict massive casualties on the Empire using "biogenic" weapons, "metaphasic" ships (both invisible and capable of flying through physical matter ) and torpedoes, ships that can fire while cloaked and last, but by no means least, the Genesis Device.
It can be difficult to compare the offensive and defensive capacities of say the Empire and the United Federation of Planets, but I would say it is certain that the defensive systems (shields) used by Starfleet are not capable of absorbing 100% of the energy from most offensive weapons systems.
Similarly, the weapons on a B-Wing (Star Wars: Rebels season two) are comparable to a starship's phasers on a higher setting. Combined with his obvious piloting skill, Vader could easily defeat Starfleet one task force at a time.
A caveat: this ultimately assumes however that Starfleet will not "fight dirty". Considering the wide array of weapons that the Federation is actually capable of using, they could inflict massive casualties on the Empire using "biogenic" weapons, "metaphasic" ships (both invisible and capable of flying through physical matter ) and torpedoes, ships that can fire while cloaked and last, but by no means least, the Genesis Device.
I've been fascinated by Anakin's statement in Phantom Menace that he dreamt he was a Jedi and "came back and freed all the slaves". What if this happened instead and was the crisis/ catalyst that started the Clone Wars and began Anakin's downfall? I suggest we see Anakin as a three-year old (perhaps) then at age ten or twelve then he leaves the Jedi Temple as part of the Trials. Around this time Palpatine is close to the (or head of) the Galactic government. He befriends Anakin and confides that Anakin's mother sold him to the Jedi Order to pay off her debts to the Hutts.
When we next hear about Anakin, the Senate is in uproar over a slave rebellion and commissions an army to either quell the rebellion or retake several hundred systems which seceded in protest at the Senate's inactions. It transpires that Anakin is (one of) the leader(s) of the rebellion which causes Kenobi to be expelled from the Jedi Order (more dramatically he could even turn to the Dark Side).
This scenario perhaps allows the Senate to issue a bounty on Kenobi which is taken up by Jango Fett. Kenobi escapes after killing Fett and orphaning Boba, which leads to him discovering the army of Fett clones purchased/commissioned on the Republic's behalf. Meanwhile, Palpatine contacts Anakin and convinces him that his rebellion is futile. Through a convoluted series of events, Anakin discovers Palpatine is also Darth Sidious. This leads him to renounce the rebellion and convince his followers to re-join the Republic. Meanwhile, Kenobi locates and confronts Anakin, which results in Anakin's permanent injuries and his acceptance of the Darth Vader persona. The reason for this is simply because Kenobi and the Jedi have no knowledge of Anakin's surrender and Palpatine's alter ego; moreover the Jedi would not inform Kenobi of any updates on current affairs while he goes off on his "idealistic crusade". Anakin's rebel ex-slaves join with the surviving clones in forming the bulk of the Imperial military.
As an addendum, Sidious deliberately sets up the Alliance to Restore the Republic hoping (or predicting) that a potential apprentice will kill and replace Vader-either through fearing that Vader will overthrow him or that Vader would soon prove unsuitable as a successor to the Sith legacy.
Friday, 16 September 2016
Final edit B5 commisioned ranks and positions
As far as I can tell based on watching episodes, the chain of command works (in terms of positions) as follows:
General
Captain
Commander
Lieutenant
so orders have to go through the commander to get to the lieutenant
I'm making an educated guess that ranks below general, based on episodes "Survivors" and "Spider in the Web" are:
Major
Captain
Commander
Lieutenant Commander
Sergeant
Lieutenant
as a partial list of Psi Corps ranks is given in "Spider in the Web" (those underlined), bearing in mind that sometimes to avoid confusion Lieutenant Commander is just Lieutenant (as in most navies), Sergeant is First Lieutenant and Lieutenant is Second Lieutenant (as in most armies)
Also, junior officers always seem to be referred to as lieutenant and, other than Major Ed Ryan, current and former starship commanders are always referred to as captain. Majors Ryan and Kemmer ( "Survivors") are described as aides to a general; the rank could be a position but this seems unlikely.
It would be easy to assume something along the lines of using staff ranks for army (i.e., Brigadier General to Five Star General) for the admiralty and navy ranks for all other commissioned officers (Captain down to ensign) but this is contradicted by the use of characters having the rank of colonel.
Garibaldi confirms the existence of admirals even though they are never seen but perhaps in the field they are referred to as either general or captain.
Update: It does seem that Earth Force officers hold two ranks simultaneously. Corwin is referred to as a Second Lieutenant in season two but he is promoted from Lieutenant (junior grade) to full Lieutenant. Takeshima is described as both a Lieutenant and Lieutenant-Commander.
I can't say that major is a position given to a general's aide because of the character Major Krantz.
I think this can be clarified if we consider Earth Force to be two organisations: the space navy and off-world security. The position of captain exists in title only.
So for the navy*:
Admiral (one to five star)
then
Commander
Lieutenant Commander
Major*
Lieutenant
Lieutenant (junior grade)
Ensign
General
Captain
Commander
Lieutenant
so orders have to go through the commander to get to the lieutenant
I'm making an educated guess that ranks below general, based on episodes "Survivors" and "Spider in the Web" are:
Major
Captain
Commander
Lieutenant Commander
Sergeant
Lieutenant
as a partial list of Psi Corps ranks is given in "Spider in the Web" (those underlined), bearing in mind that sometimes to avoid confusion Lieutenant Commander is just Lieutenant (as in most navies), Sergeant is First Lieutenant and Lieutenant is Second Lieutenant (as in most armies)
Also, junior officers always seem to be referred to as lieutenant and, other than Major Ed Ryan, current and former starship commanders are always referred to as captain. Majors Ryan and Kemmer ( "Survivors") are described as aides to a general; the rank could be a position but this seems unlikely.
It would be easy to assume something along the lines of using staff ranks for army (i.e., Brigadier General to Five Star General) for the admiralty and navy ranks for all other commissioned officers (Captain down to ensign) but this is contradicted by the use of characters having the rank of colonel.
Garibaldi confirms the existence of admirals even though they are never seen but perhaps in the field they are referred to as either general or captain.
Update: It does seem that Earth Force officers hold two ranks simultaneously. Corwin is referred to as a Second Lieutenant in season two but he is promoted from Lieutenant (junior grade) to full Lieutenant. Takeshima is described as both a Lieutenant and Lieutenant-Commander.
I can't say that major is a position given to a general's aide because of the character Major Krantz.
I think this can be clarified if we consider Earth Force to be two organisations: the space navy and off-world security. The position of captain exists in title only.
So for the navy*:
Admiral (one to five star)
then
Commander
Lieutenant Commander
Major*
Lieutenant
Lieutenant (junior grade)
Ensign
and infantry/security:
General (one to five star)
then
Colonel
Major
Commander
Lieutenant Commander
Sergeant
Lieutenant
I think it best if we assume that in general the latter ranks are generally used. Therefore a former star ship captain, Lochley, can be promoted to Colonel and a Colonel can outrank a Commander.
*The only discrepancy could be in the first series, which implies that the ranking systems used refer to that used by the Royal Air Force and most Armies, hence "Major" Kemmer.
From series two the following system could be used for the main ranks, with naval terminology only used aboard warships
General etc.
Colonel
=Captain (Navy)
Lieutenant Colonel
=Commander/(either rank referred to as) Major (with comparison to separate branches of the service)
Commander
=Lieutenant Commander (Navy)
Lieutenant Commander
=Lieutenant (Navy)
First Lieutenant
=Lieutenant (junior grade) (Navy)
(or Gunnery Sergeant in some cases)
Second Lieutenant=Ensign (Navy)
(or Pilot Officer, especially in series one referring to Sinclair's Earth Force career)
General (one to five star)
then
Colonel
Major
Commander
Lieutenant Commander
Sergeant
Lieutenant
I think it best if we assume that in general the latter ranks are generally used. Therefore a former star ship captain, Lochley, can be promoted to Colonel and a Colonel can outrank a Commander.
*The only discrepancy could be in the first series, which implies that the ranking systems used refer to that used by the Royal Air Force and most Armies, hence "Major" Kemmer.
From series two the following system could be used for the main ranks, with naval terminology only used aboard warships
General etc.
Colonel
=Captain (Navy)
Lieutenant Colonel
=Commander/(either rank referred to as) Major (with comparison to separate branches of the service)
Commander
=Lieutenant Commander (Navy)
Lieutenant Commander
=Lieutenant (Navy)
First Lieutenant
=Lieutenant (junior grade) (Navy)
(or Gunnery Sergeant in some cases)
Second Lieutenant=Ensign (Navy)
(or Pilot Officer, especially in series one referring to Sinclair's Earth Force career)
Thursday, 15 September 2016
Jack Sparks
Thought I'd post a review of "The Last Days of Jack Sparks".....on Legal Sméagol. Ha ha.
#JackSparks
Just finished named novel, couldn't help thinking of the following lyrics. Really sums the novel up, no spoilers, but the book ends up being a supernatural odyssey of self-harm and time-travelling ghosts. Or is it?
#JackSparks
Just finished named novel, couldn't help thinking of the following lyrics. Really sums the novel up, no spoilers, but the book ends up being a supernatural odyssey of self-harm and time-travelling ghosts. Or is it?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)